So it’s come to this. After decades of TV shows, movies, books, action figures, comics, “albums”, and a Saturday morning cartoon, we are at what I believe is the last crossroads for the once great Star Trek franchise.
It was announced over the weekend that J.J. Abrams, the man behind big shot mega-hit (up until recently) Lost, will be directing a new Star Trek Movie. It will be a prequel, focusing on Kirk and Spock and the like, and their days in the academy. Or something. Anyway, we’ll be looking at an all new cast, (despite probable TOS and Next Generation cameos), in an all new type of Star Trek movie.
All I can say about this is BE VERY CAREFUL.
I love Star Trek. Not in a pointy ears wearing, convention lurking sort of way, but real love all the same. I was always more of a Star Wars guy, but Trek has a special place in my heart and in my consciousness, and that place as been, in recent years, a sad one. The last good Star Trek movie was First Contact. That movie was made in 1996. Eleven years ago. The next two movies, Insurrection and Nemesis, were both terrible. The Scot Bakula fronted TV show Enterprise wasn’t much better. Oh yes, Trek apologists will try to make the case for these sub-par projects, but take it from me, a man who has spent years having to justify the almost unwatchable Star Wars prequels, the hard core Trekers are not to be believed. They love Star Trek so much that they can forgive, if not personally condone, the more embarrassing latter day sins of their beloved franchise. I completely understand where they are coming from. I have seen the Star Wars Holiday Special. There is common ground between our peoples. Star wars failed to deliver the goods with it’s 21st century revamp, and with no real prospects for new life will have trouble living on into the future. Star Wars might very well fade from cultural prominence, all because of a few bad movies (Though Sith was pretty cool.)
Let us be your cautionary tale. Your after school special. Learn from Lucas, J.J. People have a limited amount of patience, and will all to easily give up a franchise for dead. In this new Star Trek movie, Paramount has a chance to revive the franchise for the 21st century. If they fail, the public will be more than happy mothball Starfleet. It will become next to impossible to get anything off the ground. Star Trek has already almost worn out its welcome, and one more unwatchable Star Trek Product will be, at least in the short term, more than the public can take. I hope they can do the right thing.
And please, no matter who they pick for Kirk, let there be no bad Shatner Impersonations.